How to Buy Used Vinyl: A First-Copy Checklist

When you buy a vintage record, you’re choosing a particular copy. Start by deciding whether you want an affordable copy to play or a specific pressing to collect.

Identify the edition

Check the catalogue number on the sleeve and centre labels. If several editions share that number, compare the letters and numbers etched or stamped in the runout, the smooth area next to the label. Check both sides where possible. Treat an edition as unconfirmed when the details don’t match.

Read the record and sleeve grades separately

A listing marked VG+ / VG usually means the record is graded higher than the sleeve, but check the seller’s grading order. Read the notes and inspect photos of the actual copy. Look for marks across the playing surface, splits along the sleeve seams, writing on the labels and missing inserts. Ask whether the record was play-graded or inspected visually if the listing is unclear.

Ask what you can hear

If a mark crosses several grooves, ask whether it produces a repeat click or a skip. A little noise between tracks may matter less to you than noise across a quiet song. Ask for a sample of the affected passage if condition is central to your decision.

Work out the total before buying

Add postage to the asking price and compare copies of the same edition in similar condition. Check how the seller packs records and what happens if the copy arrives damaged or differs from the description. Keep a short want list and set a maximum total for each title before you start browsing.

Visit the Freak Project Vintage Vinyl Shop for its opening status or find more listening guides in the Music Magazine.